Data points
- US master file or local file obligation[5]
- None
- Prior-year revenue at which a US parent files a country-by-country report[5]
- USD 850m
- Foreign ownership of a US corporation that triggers the related-party information return[3]
- 25%
- International transactions above which India requires documentation[4]
- INR 1 crore
- Group revenue limb of India's master file test[4]
- INR 500 crore
- Indian deadline for the accountant's report on international transactions[4]
- Oct 31
- Indian penalty on the value of each international transaction with no documentation[4]
- 2%
- From when US taxpayers may rely on the simplified and streamlined distribution approach[5]
- Jan 1, 2025
The United States does not make you file a transfer pricing local file. It makes you regret not having written one. Documentation is voluntary, and preparing it on time is the only thing that takes a valuation misstatement penalty off the table.
The four facts that matter:
- There is no US master file or local file requirement. Documentation that meets the regulatory standard is what gives you penalty protection, nothing more and nothing less.
- Controlled transactions with a US entity are reported on an information return, filed with the corporate tax return, typically by the 15th day of the 4th month after year end.
- A US parent files a country-by-country report once group revenue for the prior year reaches USD 850 million.
- India tests the same transactions on its own numbers: documentation from INR 1 crore of international transactions, the accountant's report by 31 October, the master file by 30 November.
What does the United States require on a transfer pricing file?
Nothing, in the sense of a mandatory filing. The United States has no master file and no local file obligation. What it has is a penalty regime for inaccurate transfer pricing, and a documentation standard that reduces or eliminates those penalties if the file existed before the return was filed. The Internal Revenue Service publishes its transfer pricing guidance[1] for the arm's length standard itself.
That makes the US file an insurance product rather than a compliance one. It is written for the day the examiner arrives, and its value is entirely in the timestamp.
Use arrow keys to navigate cells. Enter edits or opens a row group. Escape cancels editing. Tab leaves the grid.
| United States obligation | Is it mandatory | When | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Master file | No. Not required | Not applicable | OECD |
| Local file | No. Not required | Not applicable | OECD |
| Contemporaneous documentation for penalty protection | Voluntary, but it is the only route to penalty relief | In existence when the return is filed | OECD |
| Information return on related-party transactions | Yes, where the ownership and transaction tests are met | With the corporate tax return | Internal Revenue Service |
| Country-by-country report | Yes, for a US parent above the revenue threshold | Annual | OECD |
Which US information returns cover an Indian group?
Two, and which one you file turns on which side owns which. An Indian parent with a US subsidiary files one. A US entity with Indian subsidiaries or affiliates files the other. Many groups with flows in both directions file both.
Use arrow keys to navigate cells. Enter edits or opens a row group. Escape cancels editing. Tab leaves the grid.
| Return | Who files it | What it reports | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Information return on foreign corporations[2] | US persons who are officers, directors or shareholders in certain foreign corporations | The foreign corporation's financials, ownership and transactions with the US group | Internal Revenue Service |
| Information return on foreign-owned US corporations[3] | A 25% foreign-owned US corporation, or a foreign corporation doing business in the United States | Reportable transactions with the foreign related party | Internal Revenue Service |
Both are filed with the income tax return. For a calendar-year corporation that is the 15th day of the 4th month after the year ends. The return is where the exposure starts, because the numbers on it have to match the file you did or did not write.
Talk to our transfer pricing experts
We have delivered transfer pricing for 1,000+ global businesses in 80+ countries. Book an expert call with any questions.
What does India still require on the same transactions?
Three things, on India's own thresholds, none of which moves because the counterparty is American. Documentation is required once international transactions pass INR 1 crore. The master file is a two-limb test on group revenue and transaction value. The accountant's report is filed whether or not anything else is.
Use arrow keys to navigate cells. Enter edits or opens a row group. Escape cancels editing. Tab leaves the grid.
| Indian obligation | Threshold | Deadline | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Transfer pricing documentation, the local file equivalent | International transactions above INR 1 crore (INR 10 million) | Kept, produced only if the tax authority asks | Income Tax Department, India |
| Master file | Consolidated group revenue above INR 500 crore and international transactions above INR 50 crore, or above INR 10 crore of intangibles | 30 November following the financial year | Income Tax Department, India |
| Accountant's report on international transactions | Every taxpayer with an international transaction | 31 October following the financial year | Income Tax Department, India |
| Country-by-country report | Group revenue above INR 6,400 crore (INR 64 billion) | Within 12 months of the reporting year end | Income Tax Department, India |
The thresholds and the forms behind them are set out in the OECD transfer pricing country profile for India[4]. Missing the Indian documentation costs 2% of the value of each international transaction. Missing the master file costs INR 500,000.
Where do the US and Indian rules disagree?
On whether documentation is compulsory, and on what a penalty is charged against. India charges a penalty for the missing file itself. The United States charges a penalty for the wrong price, and treats the file as the defence.
Use arrow keys to navigate cells. Enter edits or opens a row group. Escape cancels editing. Tab leaves the grid.
| Dimension | India | United States | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Is documentation required | Yes, above INR 1 crore of international transactions | No. It is voluntary and buys penalty protection | OECD |
| Master file and local file | Both, on the OECD pattern | Neither is required | OECD |
| Annual certificate | An accountant certifies the international transactions each year | None. Information returns instead | OECD |
| What a penalty attaches to | The missing document, as a percentage of transaction value | The valuation misstatement, once an adjustment is made | OECD |
| Country-by-country threshold | INR 6,400 crore of group revenue | USD 850 million of annual revenue in the prior reporting period | OECD |
| Advance pricing agreements | Unilateral, bilateral and multilateral | Unilateral, bilateral and multilateral | OECD |
A bilateral advance pricing agreement is the one instrument that settles both ends at once, and the India to US programme is among the busiest in the world.
How are India to US structures usually priced?
Four shapes cover almost every Indian group with a US entity. The method follows the functions, and the audit risk follows the gap between the functions on paper and the functions in practice.
Use arrow keys to navigate cells. Enter edits or opens a row group. Escape cancels editing. Tab leaves the grid.
| Structure | Usual method | What the two authorities test |
|---|---|---|
| Captive research and development unit in India | Cost plus, or profit split where real intangibles are created | The markup, the cost base, and who owns the resulting intangible |
| Indian distributor of US products | Transactional net margin, or resale price | The net margin against local comparables, and the treatment of rebates and discounts |
| Back office support from India | Cost plus | Cost allocation, the benefit test, and whether the service is genuinely routine |
| Shared services centre serving several US affiliates | Cost plus, or transactional net margin | The allocation keys across affiliates and the consistency of the markup |
Why do India to US transfer pricing files fail an audit?
Four failures account for most of it, and all four are drafting failures rather than pricing failures.
- A file written after the return. In the United States documentation prepared after the fact buys nothing. The timestamp is the product.
- A template from another corridor. A file that names schedules which do not exist in the United States tells the examiner nobody read the US rules.
- Missing clauses. Intangible ownership, withholding tax treatment and gross-up provisions are left out, so the two authorities reach different answers on the same payment.
- Stale markups. A markup set from a benchmark three years old is not contemporaneous in either country.
What is changing in the United States?
A notice issued on 18 December 2024 said the Treasury and the Internal Revenue Service intend to propose regulations implementing the OECD simplified and streamlined approach for baseline marketing and distribution activities. Taxpayers may rely on that approach for tax years beginning on or after 1 January 2025 until the proposed regulations are published, according to the OECD transfer pricing country profile for the United States[5].
For an Indian group with a US distributor, that is a route to a fixed return on routine distribution without a full benchmarking exercise.
How we help with US transfer pricing
The job is one analysis, used twice on two calendars. We build the functional analysis and the benchmark once, write the US documentation so it exists before the return is filed, and produce the Indian documentation and the accountant's report from the same numbers so a dual audit finds two files that agree. See how our transfer pricing software works.
Book a demo to get your India to US intercompany flows reviewed before your next return is filed.
Official sources
5 sources
- 1.Internal Revenue Service. Transfer pricing
- 2.Internal Revenue Service. About Form 5471, Information Return of U.S. Persons With Respect To Certain Foreign Corporations
- 3.Internal Revenue Service. About Form 5472, Information Return of a 25% Foreign-Owned U.S. Corporation or a Foreign Corporation Engaged in a U.S. Trade or Business
- 4.OECD. Transfer pricing country profile: India
- 5.OECD. Transfer pricing country profile: United States (October 2025)
Article by
Shrey
GM of Transfer Pricing, Commenda
Shrey is GM of Transfer Pricing at Commenda, where he leads the transfer pricing business. He works with finance and tax teams at multinational companies on intercompany pricing, documentation and benchmarking across the countries they operate in.
Disclaimer: Commenda and its affiliates do not provide tax, accounting, or legal advice. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only, and is not intended to provide or be relied on for tax, accounting, or legal advice. You should consult your own tax, accounting, and legal advisors before engaging in any related activities or transactions.








