Hiring across borders comes down to three vehicles: an Employer of Record (EOR), international contractors, or your own legal entity. Each carries a different cost, timeline, and liability profile. This guide gives you the numbers, the breakeven math, and the switch triggers so you pick once and pick right.
Should You Use an EOR, Hire International Contractors, or Open an Entity?
Use contractors for genuinely autonomous project work. Use an Employer of Record (EOR), a third party that becomes the legal employer in-country, for your first one to five employees in a market. Open a legal entity, your own registered local company, once headcount and long-term commitment justify its fixed cost. Most scaling companies run a hybrid: EOR first, entity where the market proves out.
| Model | Setup time | Upfront cost | Ongoing cost | Compliance owner and liability | Control | IP protection | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EOR | Days to ~2 weeks | Low, sometimes a deposit | $599–$699 per employee/month or 10–25% of salary | EOR is the legal employer and absorbs employment liability, but you keep misclassification and permanent establishment exposure | Moderate; you direct the work | Workable with contract diligence | First hires, market testing |
| Contractor | Immediate to days | None | ~$29 per contractor/month platform fee plus the rate | No liability separation; if classification fails, your company carries the back taxes and penalties (U.S. DOL 2024 rule) | High on output, low on process | Weakest; default ownership often sits with the creator | Short, defined projects |
| Entity | 24 hours to 9+ months | $2,000–$20,000+ to form | $15,000–$50,000+/year before salaries | Full compliance burden, but a corporate shield separates local liabilities from parent assets | Full | Strongest; direct employer assignment | Committed, long-term presence |
What Is an Employer of Record (EOR)?
An Employer of Record (EOR) is a third party that becomes the legal employer of your worker in a foreign country while you direct the day-to-day work. The EOR runs payroll, withholds and remits taxes, administers statutory benefits, issues locally compliant contracts, and absorbs employment liability. You pay the EOR a fee plus the loaded salary. It lets you hire where you have no entity.
The two pricing models are a flat per-employee fee and a percentage of salary. Remote and G-P (Globalization Partners) both publish EOR service pricing starting at $599 per employee per month, and Oyster HR starts at $699 per employee per month, per their public pricing pages. Native Teams reports the percentage model runs 10–25% of gross salary. Watch the extras covered in how to avoid hidden EOR fees.
How Is an EOR Different From a PEO?
A professional employer organization (PEO) is a co-employment model that requires you to already own a legal entity; an EOR is the sole legal employer and is the model for hiring where you have no entity. The IRS’s Certified Professional Employer Organization program, created under IRC Section 7705(a) in 2014, confirms the PEO co-employment basis. Calling an EOR “your international PEO” is wrong.
What Is an International Contractor?
An international contractor is a self-employed individual or firm engaged for services, responsible for their own taxes, benefits, and compliance. You pay an invoice, not a payroll. The model is fast and cheap, but it gives the hiring company no liability separation. If the relationship fails a classification test, your company, not the contractor, carries the back taxes, penalties, and benefit arrears. Platform management fees run about $29 per contractor per month on Remote and Oyster HR.
What Is a Legal Entity or Foreign Subsidiary?
A legal entity is a registered local company, usually a subsidiary, branch, or representative office, where you are the employer. It gives you full control and the full compliance burden. Its distinct advantage is a corporate liability shield: the subsidiary’s corporate form separates local liabilities from parent assets, which neither other model provides. Learn the fundamentals in what is a legal entity and the maintenance load in entity management.
How Much Does an EOR Cost vs. Opening a Subsidiary?
An EOR costs roughly $599–$699 per employee per month, or 10–25% of salary, and stands up in days to two weeks. Contractors cost their rate plus about $29 per contractor per month, available immediately. An entity costs $2,000–$20,000+ to form and $15,000–$50,000+ per year to run before salaries, and takes 24 hours to nine months depending on country.
| Model | Service fee | Setup time | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| EOR, flat | $599–$699 per employee/month | Days to ~2 weeks | Remote, Oyster HR, G-P public pricing |
| EOR, percentage | 10–25% of gross salary | Days to ~2 weeks | Native Teams |
| Contractor | ~$29 per contractor/month plus the rate | Immediate to days | Remote, Oyster HR public pricing |
| Entity | $2,000–$20,000+ to form; $15,000–$50,000+/year ongoing | 24 hours to 9+ months | See country table below |
Entity cost and speed swing hard by country.
| Country | Government formation cost | Timeline | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom | £100 online | Registered within 24 hours online; 8–10 days by post | UK Companies House |
| Singapore | S$315 (S$15 name + S$300 registration) | Minutes after payment; 14–60 days if referred | ACRA fees |
| Germany (GmbH) | ~€692 notary and register fees; €25,000 share capital, €12,500 paid up | Online video notarization since Aug 2022 | German GmbH Act (GmbHG) |
| Brazil | R$0 federal CNPJ fee | 23 hours average; 74.2% opened under one day (Sept 2026) | Brazil Mapa de Empresas |
What Hidden EOR Fees Should You Budget For?
Budget for deposits held against liability, FX markups on payroll conversion, off-boarding fees, statutory benefit pass-throughs, and 13th-month salary handling. These line items turn a clean $599 quote into a materially higher effective rate. The full breakdown sits in how to avoid hidden EOR fees. Compare models for your own headcount with the entity vs EOR calculator.
Deadlines Don't Wait. Neither Should You.
Annual filings, tax reports, entity upkeep — our local experts handle it all with precision. Eliminate risk and regain your time.
How Many Employees Before Opening an Entity Makes Sense?
An EOR is usually more economical up to roughly five to ten employees per country; past that, entity fixed costs amortize and win. The breakeven is simple: compare annual EOR fees for all in-country staff against amortized setup plus ongoing entity cost. High salaries on percentage-fee EORs break even faster, because the fee scales with pay.
Worked example: eight employees at 12% of a $60,000 average salary run about $57,600 per year in EOR fees. The same headcount under a local entity costs roughly $30,000 per year in operations once setup is amortized. The entity wins. Note that an entity can itself trigger day-one obligations, like India’s professional tax and provident fund registration, so time the switch deliberately.
When Should You Switch From an EOR to an Entity?
Switch when the drivers stop being about cost. The triggers are long-term strategic commitment, a need for full operational control, intellectual property (IP) consolidation, local brand credibility, equity grants to local staff, government contract eligibility, and liability separation for high-risk operations. A corporate form ring-fences local liabilities from parent assets, which neither an EOR nor a contractor arrangement can do.
Which Regulated Industries Force the Entity Decision Early?
Regulated industries such as financial services, healthcare, and pharmaceuticals often need local licenses, regulatory registrations, or data-residency arrangements that only a local entity can legally hold. These requirements can force the entity decision regardless of headcount, well before the cost breakeven arrives. Verify licensing rules in the target market before you assume an EOR will carry you.
Stay on an EOR past breakeven when the market is still unproven, political or currency risk is high, speed of exit matters, or the regulatory picture is uncertain. A paused market can hold its entity in dormant status rather than dissolving it.
What Are the Risks of Misclassifying International Contractors?
Misclassification means treating a de facto employee as a contractor based on control, integration, and economic dependence. The stakes are back taxes, social contributions, benefit arrears, fines, and interest, and the liability sits with the hiring company. The U.S. Department of Labor’s (DOL) final rule, effective March 11, 2024, applies a six-factor economic reality test to decide the question.
| Jurisdiction | Test | Penalty exposure | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| US federal (IRS) | Common-law control test; Section 3509 | 1.5% of wages + 20% of employee FICA share if 1099s filed; 3% + 40% if not; no relief for intentional disregard | IRS Internal Revenue Manual 4.23.8 |
| US federal (DOL/FLSA) | Six-factor economic reality test | Up to $2,515 per willful or repeated violation (2026) | DOL penalties |
| California | ABC test; Labor Code Section 226.8 | $5,000–$15,000 per willful violation; $10,000–$25,000 for a pattern or practice | California Labor Code 226.8 |
| United Kingdom | IR35 off-payroll rules | Back income tax, National Insurance, interest | HMRC IR35 guidance |
FICA is the Federal Insurance Contributions Act, the U.S. payroll tax. The ABC test presumes a worker is an employee unless the hirer proves all three prongs. IR35 is the UK off-payroll working rule.
How Do You Convert a Contractor to an Employee?
Convert through an EOR for speed with no entity needed, or through your own local entity when you already have one. The trigger is usually a failed or borderline classification review, a key person you cannot afford to lose, or a need to grant equity and benefits. Contractors paid by wire or by a transfer service long after the relationship became employment are the common failure case.
The steps are short. Reassess classification against the local test. Choose the vehicle, EOR or entity. Issue a compliant local employment contract. Then handle notice, tenure recognition, and a clean IP re-assignment from the old contractor agreement into the new employment terms.
What Is Permanent Establishment Risk?
Permanent establishment (PE) is when a country decides your activity creates a taxable corporate presence, exposing you to local corporate tax even without an entity. Article 5 of the OECD Model Tax Convention defines a PE as “a fixed place of business through which the business of an enterprise is wholly or partly carried on.” OECD is the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.
Contractors and even EOR-employed staff doing revenue-generating work, such as closing sales, can trigger PE. The 2025 Commentary update extends the analysis to remote and home-based work. Read the OECD Model Tax Convention for the governing language. An entity resolves PE ambiguity by design, because the local presence is already taxable and declared.
Which Model Protects Your Intellectual Property Best?
An entity protects intellectual property best. IP assignment flows through the contract chain, so the number of links decides the risk. With an entity, the worker is your employee and IP assigns to you directly under local employment law, the cleanest chain. With an EOR, IP assigns from employee to EOR to you, so you must verify the EOR’s contract includes robust assignment and onward transfer.
Contractors are the weakest link. Many jurisdictions default IP ownership to the creator absent an explicit written assignment. Custom arrangements that need side letters raise both IP and misclassification risk, which is a reason not to stay on an EOR or contractor model too long for core product work.
How Are EOR Fees, Contractor Payments, and Entity Costs Treated for Tax?
EOR invoices are generally deductible service fees to the parent with no local corporate filing. Contractor payments are deductible too, but can trigger local withholding obligations and the PE questions above. An entity shifts salaries and overhead onto a local profit and loss statement, creating corporate tax residency, local filings, and transfer pricing obligations between parent and subsidiary.
A Singapore subsidiary, for example, pays a 17% corporate income tax rate per IRAS, with a Start-Up Tax Exemption that waives 75% of the first S$100,000 of chargeable income for its first three Years of Assessment. The full cross-border treatment sits in international tax solutions.
Which Option Fits Your Situation? Six Scenarios
Scenario 1: Testing a New Market With One or Two Hires
Use an EOR. You hire in days with no entity, and you get a clean exit if the market fails. This is the lowest-commitment way to put a real person in-country and read demand before you spend on incorporation.
Scenario 2: A Defined Short-Term Project
Use contractors, with a classification check before engagement. Restate the risk from the misclassification table: full-time hours, exclusivity, and team integration flip a contractor into a de facto employee, and the hiring company carries the penalties.
Scenario 3: Committed Long-Term Market Presence
Open an entity. You get full control, direct IP assignment, local credibility, and liability separation between local operations and parent assets. Once you plan to stay, the fixed cost buys you the cleanest legal footing in the market.
Scenario 4: Rapid Multi-Market Expansion (The Hybrid Approach)
Run EOR everywhere first, then convert the markets that prove out to entities. This is the real-world answer for most scaling companies. You enter fast and compliant, keep optionality in uncertain markets, and commit capital only where traction justifies it.
Scenario 5: High-Risk or Regulated Industry
Open an entity, for two distinct reasons. First, the corporate liability shield ring-fences local risk from parent assets. Second, financial services, healthcare, and pharma often need local licenses or data-residency arrangements that only a local entity can hold, regardless of headcount.
Scenario 6: Acquiring a Company With Foreign Operations
Inherit and integrate the target’s existing entity. Its legal structure shapes the plan, and an EOR can bridge employees during integration if you need time before folding them into your structure.
How We Help You Pick and Run the Right Structure
Commenda gives you certainty about which structure fits and runs it once you choose. Commenda’s incorporation service stands up the entity when the breakeven math says switch, and Commenda’s entity management platform runs every filing after formation so country 12 behaves like country 1. For deeper reading, see the sibling guide on entity setup vs EOR and the full international tax solutions overview. Book a demo call to get a free breakeven assessment for your target country.
About the author
Logan leads Commenda’s Services and Operations team, helping controllers, heads of tax, and finance leaders navigate international expansion. He built a global expert network across 70 countries and previously worked in management consulting across the Middle East and Southeast Asia.
Disclaimer: Commenda and its affiliates do not provide tax, accounting, or legal advice. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only, and is not intended to provide or be relied on for tax, accounting, or legal advice. You should consult your own tax, accounting, and legal advisors before engaging in any related activities or transactions.






