Introduction: What Are Marketplace Facilitator Laws?

Facilitator laws have gained significance for both operators and sellers ever since the Wayfair Supreme Court ruling. They mandate online marketplaces, such as Amazon, Etsy, and eBay, to automatically collect and remit sales taxes for third-party sellers. In this case, the tax liability shifts from the seller to the individual marketplace. On the other hand, the set of laws regarding tax collection for different states are fraught with complicated nexus rules, filing requirements, and other thresholds. Regulatory scrutiny and financial penalties are additional risks that might arise.

What Does a Marketplace Facilitator Do?

A marketplace facilitator acts as an intermediary for transactions between buyers and sellers, assuming certain tax responsibilities that were previously exclusively the seller’s domain. Under these laws:

• Tax Collection & Remittance: The facilitator applies the applicable marketplace facilitator sales tax during checkout and pays it to the appropriate state authority.
• Registration: Facilitators obtain a sales tax permit in every state that has an active marketplace facilitator law.
• File Consolidation : Over the entire third-party transactions, they generate comprehensive reports, reconcile payments owed with tax collections, and file consolidated returns.
• Economic Nexus Monitoring : Numerous facilitators monitor the volumes of sales and the number of transactions to see when economic nexus thresholds are breached.

The Legal Backdrop: Wayfair Decision and Economic Nexus

Thanks to the 2018 Wayfair v. South Dakota ruling, the lack of a physical presence for the collection of sales taxes is no longer necessary. Economic presence serves as the new fulfillment criterion. This means states can demand tax collection from sellers who meet certain criteria, such as earning more than $100,000 or completing 200 transactions, regardless of having an office or physical store in the area.

This is the reason that countless states adopted marketplace facilitator laws, because tax collection is more efficient at platforms such as Amazon or Etsy compared to individual sellers. These laws assign tax responsibilities to remote sellers and facilitators when the economic nexus is achieved. Facilitators, due to different timelines for implementation, some of which are retroactive, have to monitor deadlines and compliance requirements in various jurisdictions.

State-by-State Breakdown of Marketplace Facilitator Laws

Below is a high‑level overview of each state’s key thresholds, effective dates, and notable quirks. (For full statutory text and updates, always consult the state’s Department of Revenue.).

This table illustrates the diversity in state approaches. Some states use revenue‑only thresholds; others combine transaction counts with revenue. Filing schedules vary from monthly to annual. Staying on top of these differences is paramount for any facilitator.

Common Challenges for Facilitators & Sellers

Even though seller’s marketplace facilitator laws relieve other sellers from direct collection responsibilities, the following add new burdens:  

Multi‑Jurisdiction Complexity

• Facilitators must integrate thousands of rates and update them, especially since local governments implement new rate changes as often as every week.  
• Every single county, municipality, and state has its own set of sales tax and regulatory framework.  

Varying Thresholds & Retrospective Dates

• Some states apply laws retroactively, which in turn requires facilitators to back-file returns for previous quarters.  
• The limits also differ, such as a $100,000 revenue cap in one state versus $500,000 in another.  

Data Reporting & Reconciliation Burdens

• Sellers are often required to submit detailed returns broken down by seller level so that third-party sellers can submit their returns or claim exemption.  
• Even with consolidated reporting, facilitators are still burdened with the requirement to share transaction details with sellers.  

One platform to simplify global tax and compliance

See why high-growth companies trust Commenda

Schedule a call

Marketplace Specific Exceptions  

• Certain services or digital products (for example, streaming services as opposed to digital books) may be taxed at different rates or be exempt from taxation altogether.
• Facilitators need to set up rules for product taxability by state.  

Audit Risk & Penalty Exposure  

• Interest, penalties, and audit assessments can be triggered by inaccurate rate applications or missed filings.  
• There’s liability for everyone if the marketplace is noncompliant.  

Pitfalls to Avoid:  

• Assuming one software solution covers all states, verify coverage maps.  
• Neglecting to monitor new legislation. Dozens of states update their facilitator statutes each year.  
• Overlooking transitional rules when a state gradually implements a law over multiple quarters.  

How to Stay Compliant Across States

To manage marketplace facilitator tax‑principal responsibilities and obligations, compliance requires a blend of technology, processes, and expertise:  

Sales Tax Software & Engines  

• Automated lookup and calculation accelerators: apply correct state, county and local rates at the transaction level.  
• Version control: required to honor retroactive filings by archiving historical rates.  
• Nexus tracking: sales volume and trigger monitoring per jurisdiction.  

Compliance Calendars & Workflow Automation  

• State-by-state month calendars: highlight key dates relevant to each state’s registration deadlines, filing due dates, and payment schedules.  
• Automated reminder and task assignment for registration renewals, return preparation, and payment submission.  

Professional Tax Advisory Services  

• Advise multi-state compliance by engaging specialists in sales tax and marketplace facilitator laws.
• Transactional reviews should be scheduled periodically to confirm exempt sales and validate nexus triggers.  

Seller Communication & Data Clarity  

• Issue detailed Transactional data reports to third-party sellers as needed so they can reconcile and self-file where necessary.  
• Provide portals that allow self-management for the collection and issuance of exemption certificates.  

Continuous Legislative Analysis  

• Track state sessions for law proposals and tax bills actively.  
• Actively participate in public commentary and draft policy consultations to shape favorable rules.  

If you are analyzing options, browse Commenda’s dedicated, robust solutions for sales tax as well as facilitator compliance services.

Using Commenda for Marketplace Tax Compliance

Commenda’s platform fully equips users for compliance with all mandates of marketplace facilitator laws, integrating them into one solution that combines workflow automation with professional consultation: 

• Centralized Document Repository  

Keep all state registrations, resale certificates, exemption documents, and audit trails in a locked hub with a comprehensive search, and retain perpetual access.  

• Automated Compliance Tracking  

Get instant notifications in real-time for economic nexus thresholds, law changes, and impending contractual filing deadlines.  

• Rate Engine & Taxability Library  

Utilise over 14,000 tax jurisdictions with state and industry-specific product taxability guidelines stored in an ever-growing repository. Access to information has never been easier.  

• Advanced Reporting & Tax Recon  

Access seller grouped and aggregate reporting, cross-reference exported data with prominent accounting or ERP systems, and harmonize taxes collected versus remitted.

• Professional Assistance & Advisory

Count on our U.S. sales tax specialists for any inquiries regarding nexus, sourcing rules, or complicated exemption situations.  

Through Commenda, managed marketplaces can flawlessly handle hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of transactions, slash audit exposure, and enable sellers to concentrate on fueling business expansion instead of worrying about tax compliance. Want to see it in action? Schedule a demo today and check our in-depth case studies.

Conclusion: Stay Ahead of Marketplace Tax Changes

Marketplace facilitator laws have emerged in response to the Wayfair decision, changing the roles of online platforms and sellers. Even though these laws provide relief to individual sellers by forcing marketplace facilitators to deal with a complex web of state rules, reporting thresholds, and complex reporting requirements, automation tools, streamlined compliance calendars, and marketplace facilitators remove the burden of labyrinthine state rules on sellers and platform entities like Commenda, ensuring turning automation compliance becomes a competitive advantage fosters growth.

FAQ: Marketplace Facilitator Laws

1. Do small sellers qualify as marketplace facilitators?

• Yes, as long as a seller operates a platform where third parties can sell and complies with a state’s economic nexus threshold, which could be $100,000 in sales or 200 transactions, they qualify. However, these definitions differ from state to state.

1. What if I sell on multiple platforms?

• Each marketplace (Amazon, Etsy) has its own ecosystem for tax collection, and buyers are responsible for keeping track of their total sales on different platforms to assess their nexus status. 
• Can a seller opt out of facilitator tax collection?
• No, generally speaking. Once a marketplace satisfies the necessary criteria to be considered a facilitator in a given state, it must collect sales tax on all taxable sales. Unless there is an exemption provided, sellers can’t choose not to participate.  
• How are refunds and returns handled?
• Facilitators are responsible for making changes to tax reports for refunds processed. Most states require tax modifications to be done within a certain time frame, which is usually 180 days.  
• How often do state laws change?  
• The monitoring of compliance, however, is critical for compliance. States revise and set new limits, taxability of new products or services, and filing rules.